New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso has been absolutely phenomenal to kick off the 2025 season, reminding everyone why he’s considered one of baseball’s elite. With a remarkable .341 batting average, six home runs under his belt, and an incredible OPS of 1.122, Alonso is driving the Mets’ offense in a way that has fans buzzing. The team has surged to a 7-0 homestand, claiming the best record in baseball, and Alonso’s contributions are a huge part of that success. However, despite his sizzling start, questions loom over his future with the Mets, especially regarding a contract extension.
Renowned sports journalist Jon Heyman has weighed in on the situation, stating, “I don’t think we’re gonna get any news regarding a contract extension during the season. The hitch is that Alonso is likely looking at a demand of $35 million per year, which adds another $5 million this year and some hefty tax implications. Even someone like Steve Cohen has his limits, so I find it hard to believe that will happen.”
Under Cohen’s ownership, the Mets have shown a willingness to invest big bucks, but their front office has been cautious about locking in long-term deals for players approaching 30. Heyman also pointed out that Alonso’s potential contract would pile on significant costs for the Mets’ payroll, complicating negotiations even further.
Despite these hurdles, Alonso’s performance this season solidifies his spot as one of the most formidable players in the National League. His contributions have been pivotal for a Mets team that’s poised for success; they’re stepping onto the field with the best record in Major League Baseball as they face off against the Nationals. As he continues to stay healthy and deliver at the plate, Alonso has established himself as one of the league’s premier hitters, all while competing in the shadow of Aaron Judge’s electrifying season with the Yankees.
This April, Alonso has been nothing short of a powerhouse, even outshining some of the game’s top talents. Consider this: he’s matching some of the output of stars like Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who recently inked a record 14-year, $500 million deal with the Toronto Blue Jays. With six home runs and 16 RBIs so far, Alonso’s stats are strikingly similar to Judge’s. His OPS of 1.121 places him just behind Judge’s impressive 1.247, showcasing that he’s a consistent power hitter in baseball’s landscape.
Off the field, Alonso’s contract situation has sparked plenty of chatter. Although formal discussions for an extension haven’t taken place yet between him and the Mets, that could shift once the season wraps up and he hits free agency. The Mets front office, known for treading carefully when it comes to lengthy agreements for players on the brink of 30, will have to make a tough choice: should they offer Alonso a long-term contract or risk letting him explore potentially better offers elsewhere?
Alonso himself has navigated a whirlwind offseason filled with uncertainty about his future with the Mets. Yet, he’s found a sense of belonging on the team, sharing, “I always had faith that things would unfold the way they were meant to, and I’d ultimately end up where I was supposed to be.” For now, it certainly seems like his place is still with the Mets, and his electric performance this season only boosts his case for a long-term deal—if the Mets decide they’re willing to meet his price.
Image Source: Pete Alonso @ Instagram
